Adsterra

Same-Sex Adoption & Parental Rights: Laws, Challenges & Future

Lawkagyan February 07, 2025

Same-Sex Adoption & Parental Rights: Laws, Challenges & Future

Introduction

In India, same-sex adoption and parental rights remain among the most debated and unresolved legal issues. While LGBTQ+ rights have progressed in the last decade, with Section 377 decriminalized in 2018, same-sex couples still face significant legal and social barriers to adoption.

Unlike many Western nations, India has no formal recognition of same-sex couples, making adoption and parental rights a major challenge. The Supreme Court's 2023 decision, which denied same-sex couples the right to adopt, sparked debates on family structures, cultural acceptance, and legal equality.


This article explores same-sex adoption in India, legal challenges, cultural barriers, the role of the judiciary, and the path forward for LGBTQ+ family rights.

Historical Background of LGBTQ+ Rights in India

India’s legal stance on LGBTQ+ rights has evolved significantly, but progress remains slow.

1. Section 377 and Its Decriminalization (2018)

For over 150 years, Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code criminalized same-sex relationships, classifying them as "unnatural offenses."

  • 2018 (Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India) – The Supreme Court struck down Section 377, decriminalizing homosexuality.
  • The ruling was a major milestone but did not grant same-sex couples the right to marry or adopt children.

2. The Fight for Marriage Equality & Adoption Rights

  • 2022-2023: LGBTQ+ activists filed petitions in the Supreme Court seeking marriage equality under the Special Marriage Act.
  • 2023 (Same-Sex Marriage Case): The Supreme Court declined to legalize same-sex marriage, stating it was up to Parliament to make laws on the subject.

3. Early LGBTQ+ Activism in India

Organizations like Naz Foundation, Humsafar Trust, and Sweekar – The Rainbow Parents have played a crucial role in advocating for LGBTQ+ rights, including adoption and family rights.

Legal Status of Same-Sex Adoption in India

1. Existing Laws on Adoption in India

Currently, Indian law does not recognize LGBTQ+ couples as legal parents. The adoption process is governed by:

✅ Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act (HAMA) (1956): Allows only married heterosexual couples or single individuals to adopt.

✅ Juvenile Justice Act (2015): Governs adoption for non-Hindus but does not explicitly allow same-sex couples to adopt.

✅ Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA): The regulatory body does not permit same-sex couples to apply for adoption.

2. Supreme Court’s 2023 Decision on Same-Sex Adoption

  • In October 2023, the Supreme Court ruled that same-sex couples do not have an automatic right to adopt children.
  • The Court stated that adoption laws only recognize heterosexual, married couples.
  • Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud dissented, arguing that denying same-sex couples the right to adopt was discriminatory.

3. Lack of Legal Recognition of LGBTQ+ Families

  • Same-sex couples cannot adopt jointly—only single LGBTQ+ individuals can adopt.
  • Parental rights are not recognized for same-sex partners, creating custody and inheritance challenges.
  • No legal framework exists to protect children of same-sex parents in cases of separation or death.


Social and Cultural Barriers to Same-Sex Adoption in India

Even if adoption laws change, same-sex parents in India will face deep-rooted cultural resistance.

1. Traditional Indian Family Values & Opposition to LGBTQ+ Parenting

  • Indian society places strong emphasis on the "ideal" family unit—a father, mother, and children.
  • Many Indians still associate LGBTQ+ relationships with Western influence, making same-sex parenting socially unacceptable in many regions.

2. Public Opinion on LGBTQ+ Adoption Rights

A 2022 YouGov India survey found that:

  • 57% of Indians believe children should be raised by a mother and a father.
  • Only 29% supported same-sex couples having adoption rights.
  • Urban areas (like Mumbai, Delhi, and Bangalore) show more acceptance compared to rural India.

3. Challenges LGBTQ+ Parents Face in Indian Society

  • Schools may refuse admission to children of LGBTQ+ parents.
  • Relatives and neighbors may discriminate against same-sex families.
  • Workplaces may not recognize LGBTQ+ parental benefits, such as maternity/paternity leave.

The Impact of Same-Sex Parenting on Children

One of the biggest arguments against same-sex adoption in India is the concern for child welfare. Opponents claim that children need a mother and father for proper development. However, scientific studies and expert opinions prove that same-sex parenting has no negative effects on child development.

1. Scientific Studies on Same-Sex Parenting and Child Development

Several international and India-based studies have explored how children of same-sex parents compare to those raised by heterosexual couples.

Key Research Findings:

✅ American Psychological Association (APA) Study (2005):

  • No difference in emotional, cognitive, or social development between children of same-sex and heterosexual parents.

✅ Columbia University Study (2021):

  • Analyzed 75+ research papers and found no evidence that same-sex parenting harms children.

✅ National Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences (NIMHANS), India (2022):

  • Found that children raised by same-sex parents in India were as emotionally stable as those in heterosexual families.
  • The study emphasized the need for social acceptance to prevent bullying and discrimination.

Expert Opinion:

Dr. Ashwini Kumar, Child Psychologist (AIIMS, Delhi):

"A child's well-being depends on emotional security and parental love, not the gender of their parents. The biggest challenge for children of same-sex couples is societal discrimination, not their family structure."

2. Common Myths About Same-Sex Parenting in India

MythReality
Children need both a mother and a father for healthy development.Studies confirm that same-sex parents provide the same level of emotional and financial support as heterosexual couples.
Kids raised by same-sex parents will be bullied.Bullying is a societal issue, not a parenting issue. Educating people about LGBTQ+ families can reduce discrimination.
LGBTQ+ parents will raise children to be LGBTQ+.Sexual orientation is not influenced by parents—heterosexual parents also raise LGBTQ+ children.


Role of the Indian Judiciary in LGBTQ+ Adoption Rights

The Indian judiciary has played a pivotal role in shaping LGBTQ+ rights. However, same-sex adoption remains a grey area, with courts reluctant to challenge traditional family laws.

1. Notable Supreme Court Cases Affecting LGBTQ+ Families

1. Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India (2018)

✅ Decriminalized homosexuality in India by striking down Section 377.

✅ Recognized LGBTQ+ individuals' dignity and rights.

❌ Did not grant marriage or adoption rights to same-sex couples.

2. Same-Sex Marriage Case (2023)

✅ Heard petitions to legalize same-sex marriage under the Special Marriage Act.

❌ Supreme Court ruled that Parliament, not the judiciary, should decide on marriage and adoption rights.

3. Adoption Rights Ruling (2023)

✅ Allowed unmarried LGBTQ+ individuals to adopt but not same-sex couples.

✅ Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud dissented, arguing that same-sex couples should be recognized as legal parents.

Legal Loophole:

Since single LGBTQ+ individuals can adopt, many same-sex couples bypass the system by one partner adopting as a "single parent". However, this creates legal issues with inheritance, custody, and guardianship.

The Future of LGBTQ+ Family Rights in India

While legal barriers remain, India is slowly moving towards greater acceptance of LGBTQ+ families.

1. Steps Towards Legalizing Same-Sex Adoption in India

To achieve full adoption rights, activists are focusing on:

📌 Petitions to amend adoption laws to recognize same-sex couples as legal parents.

📌 Lobbying Parliament to update the Juvenile Justice Act and Hindu Adoption and Maintenance         Act.

📌 Raising awareness to increase public acceptance of LGBTQ+ families.

2. Importance of Public Awareness and Social Acceptance

Laws alone cannot change societal attitudes. Public perception plays a key role in shaping policies.

  • Increased LGBTQ+ representation in Bollywood and mainstream media can help normalize LGBTQ+ families.
  • Education programs in schools can reduce misconceptions about same-sex parenting.
  • Public endorsements by celebrities, religious leaders, and politicians can help shift social attitudes.

3. Policy Recommendations and Legislative Changes

For India to recognize same-sex adoption, lawmakers should consider:

✅ Amending the Juvenile Justice Act (2015) to allow same-sex couples to adopt.

✅ Creating a gender-neutral adoption law that focuses on parenting ability, not sexual orientation.

✅ Ensuring equal parental rights in areas like custody, inheritance, and legal guardianship.

Lessons from Other Countries:

📌 Taiwan (2022): Legalized same-sex adoption after legalizing same-sex marriage in 2019.

📌 France (2013): Allowed LGBTQ+ couples to adopt, despite strong opposition from religious groups.

📌 Brazil (2010): Recognized same-sex couples as legal parents without marriage requirements.

India can learn from these examples to create inclusive adoption laws while addressing public concerns.

Conclusion

The fight for same-sex adoption and parental rights in India is still in its early stages. While LGBTQ+ rights have progressed significantly since Section 377 was decriminalized in 2018, same-sex couples still face legal discrimination in adoption laws.

The scientific consensus is clear—same-sex parents are just as capable as heterosexual parents, and their children grow up just as healthy and happy. The real challenge is societal bias, not family structure.

To move forward, India needs legal reforms, social awareness, and stronger advocacy efforts. The future of LGBTQ+ parental rights depends on continued activism, judicial progress, and shifting societal attitudes.

📌 India must recognize that family is built on love, not gender or sexual orientation.

FAQs

1. Is same-sex adoption legal in India?

No. Same-sex couples cannot adopt, but single LGBTQ+ individuals are allowed to adopt under current laws.

2. What are the biggest challenges for LGBTQ+ parents in India?

✅ Legal barriers (adoption laws, inheritance, custody issues)

✅ Social stigma and discrimination

✅ Lack of institutional support for LGBTQ+ families

3. Are there any organizations supporting same-sex adoption rights in India?

Yes. Groups like Naz Foundation, Humsafar Trust, and Sweekar – The Rainbow Parents are actively advocating for LGBTQ+ family rights.

4. Has the Indian Supreme Court ruled on LGBTQ+ parental rights?

Yes. In 2023, the Supreme Court ruled against same-sex adoption, stating that Parliament must decide on family laws.

5. What steps can be taken to legalize LGBTQ+ adoption in India?

📌 Petition Parliament to amend adoption laws.

📌 Raise public awareness about LGBTQ+ families.

📌 Push for gender-neutral family laws.

Post a Comment

0 Comments